Lose the ID3 tag sorting

What is the point of using ID3 tag sorting? I just got my second player that uses this system. Sure, I oohed and ahhed over it for the first few minutes when I first saw it. In practice, though, it really isn’t that great of a system. If you have even a modestly diverse collection of music, you’ll end up with a bewildering number of different albums, artist, and genres. I almost never use the artist or album sort because there are just too many, and the only reason I can use the genre sorting is because I changed the genre of anything that is even reasonably close in style to a generic term like ‘rock,’ or ‘country’, or ‘soundtrack’
Which is approximately how I have the folders organized on my pc (generic genre => artist=>album). So if the player just used a directory tree type folder sort, navigation would be the same as the genre sort is for me right now except compilation/ sampler cds wouldn’t complicate things. All I’d have to do is move the root folders - as is -on to the player and I’d be able to find everything. No more confusion caused by compilation, and I’d stop having to wait 5 minutes for it to refresh the entire collection every time I make a change or so much as take the microsd card out.

9 replies