HELP: Repeated SanDisk V90 Card Failure on Lumix S5 II (Need Real Feedback – Not Basic Troubleshooting)

Hey everyone,
I’m reaching out for some real support and insight. I’ve now had two SanDisk Extreme Pro 128GB V90 SD cards fail on me during a shoot — nine months apart — both under similar circumstances. These are not cheap cards, and the loss of footage is beyond frustrating.

Here’s my detailed breakdown:

Camera & Setup Info
  • Camera: Panasonic Lumix S5 II

  • Firmware: Latest version (fully up to date)

  • Cards: SanDisk Extreme Pro 128GB V90 UHS-II

  • Total Cards Owned: ~15 (all high-end SanDisk V90s)

The Problem (Occurred Twice, 9 Months Apart)
  • Issue: Card corrupts during a shoot.

  • Error Message: “Please insert SD card” appears mid-shoot.

  • Result: Card is not recognized by camera or computer. Recovery software fails to even read it.

Common Denominators in Both Card Failures
  1. Old Footage on Card:
  • I did not format the card before the shoot because it had footage from earlier that day or a previous session.
  1. Frequent Playback During Shoot:
  • I was reviewing and playing back clips often during the shoot.

  • Then switching back and forth between playback and shooting mode — probably 20+ times that day.

  1. Failure Occurred During Transition:
  • Card failed right as I transitioned from playback mode back to shooting mode.
Recovery Attempts (Both Times)
  • Tried 3 different computers and 2 other cameras.

  • Tried multiple recovery software programs.

  • In both cases: Card not even recognized = cannot recover data.

  • Important distinction: If the card had simply been corrupted, I could have used recovery software to retrieve the footage. But because it was a complete card failure, the card couldn’t be read at all — making recovery impossible.

  • The only theory I can come up with is that there may have been some sort of electrical short or glitch when the camera transitions from playback to shooting mode — it’s the only moment that lines up in both cases, and the only thing that remotely makes sense at this point.

  • Conclusion: Not a corruption issue — total card failure.

My Usual Workflow (for the past 9 months):
  • I always use a freshly formatted card before every shoot.

  • I follow best practices with formatting in-camera before use.

  • These two failures are the only exceptions (where I didn’t freshly format before shooting).

My Questions for the Group:
  • Is this a camera issue (Lumix S5 II)?

  • Is it a card brand issue (SanDisk V90)?

  • Or do I absolutely have to freshly format every card before every use, even if the card already has footage from the same camera/session?

  • Has anyone else had issues switching between playback and shooting modes and encountering this kind of error?

Final Notes:
  • All footage was recorded on the same camera and left in the same card. No cross-camera or card swaps.

  • I’ve contacted both SanDisk and Panasonic — both gave me basic troubleshooting and provided no help.

  • I’m looking for real feedback or insights to avoid this happening again.

Any help is appreciated. Thank you!

6 replies