SmartWare? Or DumbWare?

I thought I understood and was comfortable with WD SmartWare’s continuous backup as a complete backup solution. I’ve been using it (with a My Book drive) for over a year now, so when my data drive recently failed I felt confident that I was in good shape. I bought a new drive and retreived all my data from the SmartWare backup. Sounds good, right?

The first hint that there was a problem came in the form of a message that my Dropbox was full. How could that be, I thought, since I always manage my Dropbox at about 80% of capacity. A little digging around in my files and it started to look like "Smart"Ware had recovered files that I had long ago deleted from my computer.

How does that make sense for a complete backup solution? I mean, how do they imagine that I’m going to use it? Every time I delete a file from my computer am I supposed to go digging around in the backup to delete it from there as well? I just don’t get it. I’d call that Dumbware. So is my data drive now crammed with all my current data plus every file I’ve deleted in the past year and a half or so? How will I ever clean that mess up? The answer is, I can’t.

If anyone can explain how this is supposed to be a good idea, let alone “Smart”, I’d love to hear it. Also, if I’ve just been using it wrong, please tell me what I need to do to use it correctly. Otherwise, does anyone know of a continuous backup solution that is actually Smart, (meaning that when I delete files from my computer it deletes them from the continuous backup as well)?

Thanks.

1
4 replies